14 Comments
User's avatar
Joe's avatar

Here’s a partial list of why the Republicans were creamed a few weeks ago:

Iran war when one of the most prominent specific planks of 2024 was no new foreign wars.

Transparency around Epstein. “Are you still talking about him? We don’t want you.”(DJT)

The absolute total indifference to the plight of the American farmer and small businessman From the crushing impact of tariffs and the Iran war. Couples that with the propagate spending on stupid shit, like the White House ballroom and the “let them eat cake” attitude of the Republican/MAGA blue bloods which cost them Mississippi for goodness sake (“ there are many kinds of protein to choose from.”

The staffing of Trump 2.0 almost entirely with neocon establishment figures when we were promised the exact opposite. The overt, total contempt that these people had for the American working class and the people who put them in power was not even attempted to be hidden.

I could go on for another page or two but, as much as Voter registration can be an important indicator of which way in election is going to go, when you’re faced with the biggest rug poll of American electoral politics in my lifetime, that stuff doesn’t even matter. I highly suggest talking to the checkout clerks at target, the guys playing darts at your local Social Club, the small businesses sliding head, long into bankruptcy and give their opinion more weight than party registration or poles or any of that stuff.

We voted for America first, but got Netanyahu, Lindsay, Graham, Marco Rubio, Lutnick, and the entirety of the Epstein class, flaunting their wealth and power while they watched us in our small businesses circling the drain.

Ballot harvesting and election corruption can count for some of the shift, but doesn’t come near to explaining the election results. To understand what happened, it’s well worth taking a listen to the absolute disgust and revulsion that a large majority of Americans have for what’s going on in Washington right now

Howard Audsley's avatar

Capt. Seth: Are you certain that all the new voter registrations are legit? If put to a 3 way test, would all those new voters come out the other end unscathed and confirmed legit? As for me, until I hear that has been done and they are in fact, real, legit voters, I remain skeptical. The widespread, happened everywhere, across the board flip just doesn't pass the smell test.

Capt. Seth Keshel's avatar

I’m not confident, especially in NC/PA or any urban spaces where they blew up our gains. I think they sponsored big drives to reverse the declines people are now beginning to talk about.

But we also have coalition issues and political problems to address in conjunction with the corruption issues of the other side.

Richard Luthmann's avatar

Part of the problem is that Republicans die much more quickly on the voting rolls. If you're a Democrat worth your weight in salt, you'll stick around and vote in at least two or three presidential elections after you've taken your dirt nap.

Capt. Seth Keshel's avatar

Yep, my Dad died in 2010 and has probably been voting Dem ever since.

VikingMom's avatar

I have the same question as Howard. Yes, the Iran conflict affected some percentage of voters especially younger ones who maybe cast their first vote in 2024, thinking that Donald Trump was going to be able to follow through on ALL of his campaign promises immediately. So I get the flip in the 18-29 year old contingent. And the media highlighted the high gas prices and the continued economic impact from them ad infinitum so that did not help the Republicans either.

But, the massive flip in some of the races is still puzzling, especially since no one, including you, seemed to see it coming. You have been such a great source for accurate information and reasonable predictions that I have to ask if you are completely comfortable with the results as reported?

There were several voices questioning the uniformity of the percentage of the vote shift in numerous races, but I haven't heard of anyone in any race, anywhere, challenging the results.

Would like to hear your thoughts on that or are we just moving forward from here, regardless of how odd the whole thing looks?

Capt. Seth Keshel's avatar

Midterms are much harder to predict than presidentials. I had it directionally right in the House. No one had the magnitude.

Many states have laws making it easier to pick off seats they wouldn’t win even in a good year for them - CO-4 is a prime example.

I don’t trust the integrity of elections when we WIN; let alone when we don’t. But what people are drawing a blank on is the means to get the desired transparency. We fail to pursue it when we win and are in a better position to see how much cheating was overcome.

On the other side of it - I think we do ourselves a major disservice to think the other side won’t vote like gang busters given how much they’ve been indoctrinated to hate us/Trump, or to believe that Iran has been a positive for our movement from an electoral standpoint.

VikingMom's avatar

Thank you for responding! I really appreciate your well reasoned and thoughtful perspective. I know the level of TDS is higher than most sane people realize and that did play into the results.

I also think most sane people are aware that our election systems are an absolute mess and therefore, not trustworthy, at the best of times, but again, because of the level of TDS, there is no one on the Left, or in the media (but I repeat myself) willing to touch the issue.

Not sure where we go from here - "vote harder" ain't working, especially when the majority of people we DO elect on the R side of the aisle refuse to actually do their jobs...

Capt. Seth Keshel's avatar

Well, it’s a complicated answer. I think my Saturday piece gives my best thoughts on that. I think we have exchanged long-term success and prosperity for short term wins held under the guise of “the most important election ever.” All of this is made possible by an affluent society that didn’t feel the pain until it was right in front of it as an existential threat.

There are also tens of millions of Christians who do not vote, so it’s not ALL corruption and fraud. It is simply made easier by their absence.

JTURNER's avatar

Of all the Free State talk in NH, I think it's fool's gold. MA residents escape to NH to avoid MA taxes and then promptly vote D. I lived in MA for 3 years. Trying to convince people to move to a state that's frigid 8 months out of the year is a steep sell.

Capt. Seth Keshel's avatar

Tend to concur.

The Great Santini's avatar

I understand Trump’s determination to solve the Iran Problem. However he made two mistakes. The first, not explaining to the nation the need for this action. The second, not pursuing it all-out to its conclusion after having started.

The pause to negotiate should have been exceedingly short and the operation resumed promptly and aggressively once the Iranians started prevaricating. Also negotiations and threats by X and Truth Social are not effective and trouble the American people.

The second mistake was caused by Trump thinking he can make a deal with anybody. That’s not true. There is no deal with the Mullahs and the IRGC. This is a fight to the death with an implacable foe. The sooner we internalize that the better.

And frankly, Ukraine is the same way. The Ukraine war will continue until Putin thinks that he must surrender or be destroyed or until he and his supporters are removed from power.

The world does not conform to our wishes. We learn to face reality and make our plans in light of that truth or reality’s will bite us in the ass.

Capt. Seth Keshel's avatar

Your first point, IMO, is your best. We are constantly outflanked in the information war.

James M.'s avatar

I was sick during the midterms (we teachers had the day off school, but were still expected to come in for meetings and professional training), but I still voted.

Nevertheless, voting is beginning to feel more and more like a rear-guard action. The lion's share of our efforts must go towards building our communities, constructing efforts of ideological sympathy and mutual aid, and beginning to intentionally and openly separate ourselves from the more pathological and parasitic elements of our culture.

Voting won't fix them.

https://jmpolemic.substack.com/p/were-not-voting-our-way-out